In May 2026, Mister Pizza Elmwood was temporarily closed to undergo renovations and transition to new ownership.
Mister Pizza Elmwood has entered an exciting new era under the ownership of Michael Vaccaro and Dominic Pennacchio. With deep roots in Buffalo and a passion for food and hospitality, Mike and Dominic bring fresh energy while honoring everything that made Mister Pizza a local favorite.
Their vision is to preserve the authenticity and tradition customers expect, while elevating the experience through improved operations, expanded offerings, and a renewed focus on quality and consistency. From modernizing the ordering experience to refining recipes and service, their goal is to make Mister Pizza Elmwood better than ever—without losing its identity.
Under new ownership, Mister Pizza Elmwood remains committed to the community it serves. Whether it’s late-night slices, quick delivery, or feeding a crowd, the mission is simple: stay reliable, stay local, and keep delivering the food Buffalo loves.
This isn’t just a relaunch—it’s a continuation of a legacy, backed by a new generation dedicated to keeping Mister Pizza Elmwood a cornerstone of Elmwood Avenue for years to come.
Mister Pizza Elmwood has long been a staple of Buffalo’s Elmwood Village—serving up classic pies, late-night slices, and a neighborhood atmosphere that generations of customers have come to love. Known for its no-nonsense approach to great pizza, the shop built its reputation on consistency, quality ingredients, and being a go-to spot whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or ending a night out in the city.
For years, Mister Pizza Elmwood has been part of the rhythm of Elmwood Avenue—fueling college students, families, and Buffalo locals alike. Its familiar menu and fast, reliable service made it more than just a pizza shop—it became part of the community fabric. From its signature slices to its classic wings and subs, the focus has always been simple: good food, done right.
